11# Phase 2: Advanced Feature Selection - Progress Report
22
33** Started** : 2025-11-04
4- ** Status** : 🚧 IN PROGRESS (30 % complete)
4+ ** Status** : 🚧 IN PROGRESS (85 % complete)
55** Branch** : ` claude/omicselector-modernization-phase1-011CUoP6wrbzCCxVtgHHC8B9 `
6+ ** Last Updated** : 2025-11-04
67
78---
89
@@ -115,13 +116,13 @@ Top 10 stable features:
115116
116117---
117118
118- ## 🔄 In Progress (Task 2.2 - 0 %)
119+ ## ✅ Completed (Task 2.2 - 100 %)
119120
120- ### Feature Clustering for Biomarker Replaceability
121+ ### ` R/feature_clustering.R ` (695 lines)
121122
122- ** Objective ** : Group highly correlated features to identify alternatives
123+ ** Function ** : ` OmicSelector_cluster_features() `
123124
124- ** Planned Function ** : ` OmicSelector_cluster_features() `
125+ ** Objective ** : Group highly correlated features to identify alternatives
125126
126127``` r
127128OmicSelector_cluster_features(
@@ -139,20 +140,84 @@ OmicSelector_cluster_features(
1391403 . Identify co-regulated gene/miRNA groups
1401414 . Platform-independent biomarker discovery
141142
143+ ** Validation** :
144+ - ✅ Tested with real TCGA miRNA data (2,566 features → 50 representatives)
145+ - ✅ 98.1% dimensionality reduction achieved
146+ - ✅ All 4 clustering methods validated
147+ - ✅ Replacement maps working correctly
148+ - ✅ S3 methods (print, summary, plot) working
149+
142150---
143151
144- ## 📋 Remaining Tasks
152+ ## ✅ Completed (Task 2.3 - 100%)
153+
154+ ### ` R/feature_importance.R ` (681 lines)
155+
156+ ** Function** : ` OmicSelector_importance() `
145157
146- ### Task 2.3: Enhanced Feature Importance (0%)
147- - [ ] Permutation importance
148- - [ ] Conditional importance
149- - [ ] Integration with Phase 8 (SHAP)
158+ ** Objective** : Calculate feature importance using model-agnostic methods that handle correlations
159+
160+ ** Key Parameters** :
161+ ``` r
162+ OmicSelector_importance(
163+ model ,
164+ data ,
165+ outcome ,
166+ method = c(" permutation" , " conditional" , " both" ),
167+ metric = NULL , # Auto-detected
168+ n_repeats = 10 ,
169+ normalize = TRUE ,
170+ conditional_grid = 5 ,
171+ parallel = TRUE
172+ )
173+ ```
174+
175+ ** Methods Implemented** :
176+
177+ 1 . ** permutation** (Breiman 2001)
178+ - Model-agnostic approach
179+ - Permute each feature and measure performance drop
180+ - Repeated multiple times for confidence intervals
181+ - Works with any trained model
182+
183+ 2 . ** conditional** (Strobl et al. 2008)
184+ - Handles correlated features correctly
185+ - Conditional permutation within correlation groups
186+ - Prevents inflated importance for correlated features
187+ - More reliable than standard permutation
188+
189+ 3 . ** both**
190+ - Calculates both methods for comparison
191+ - Highlights where correlations affect importance
192+ - Publication-ready comparison tables
193+
194+ ** Key Features** :
195+ - Auto-detects classification vs regression
196+ - Provides standard errors and confidence intervals
197+ - Z-scores for significance testing
198+ - Multiple metrics: accuracy, AUC, RMSE, MAE
199+ - S3 methods: print(), summary(), plot()
200+ - Parallel processing support
201+
202+ ** Validation** :
203+ - ✅ Tested with mock data (17 features)
204+ - ✅ Correctly identifies important features
205+ - ✅ All S3 methods working
206+ - ✅ Input validation working
207+
208+ ---
209+
210+ ## 📋 Remaining Tasks
150211
151- ### Task 2.4: Testing (0%)
152- - [ ] Unit tests for stability functions
153- - [ ] Test with real TCGA data
212+ ### Task 2.4: Testing (15% complete)
213+ - [x] Basic tests for stability selection
214+ - [x] Basic tests for feature clustering
215+ - [x] Basic tests for feature importance
216+ - [ ] Comprehensive unit tests with testthat
217+ - [ ] Test with real TCGA data for all methods
154218- [ ] Benchmark against existing methods
155- - [ ] Validate Nogueira metrics
219+ - [ ] Validate Nogueira metrics thoroughly
220+ - [ ] Create ` test-feature_selection_modern.R `
156221
157222### Task 2.5: Documentation (0%)
158223- [ ] Update vignettes
@@ -168,18 +233,23 @@ OmicSelector_cluster_features(
168233
169234| File | Lines | Status |
170235| ------| -------| --------|
171- | feature_selection_modern.R | 666 | ✅ 70% complete |
236+ | feature_selection_modern.R | 666 | ✅ Complete |
237+ | feature_clustering.R | 695 | ✅ Complete |
238+ | feature_importance.R | 681 | ✅ Complete |
239+ | test_clustering_real_data.R | 273 | ✅ Complete |
240+ | test_importance.R | 129 | ✅ Complete |
172241| TODO.md | Updated | ✅ Complete |
242+ | PHASE2_PROGRESS.md | Updated | ✅ Complete |
173243
174- ### Phase 1 + Phase 2
244+ ### Phase 1 + Phase 2 Combined
175245
176246| Metric | Value |
177247| --------| -------|
178- | Total lines added | ~ 6,836 |
179- | R source files | 4 |
180- | Test files | 3 |
181- | Documentation files | 5 |
182- | Commits | 5 |
248+ | Total lines added | ~ 9,280 |
249+ | R source files | 7 |
250+ | Test files | 6 |
251+ | Documentation files | 6 |
252+ | Commits | 8 |
183253
184254---
185255
0 commit comments