project title:
run ID:
output mode: demo report / technical appendix / decision brief / review packet / dashboard or table package / manuscript or paper / slide deck / web page or interactive report / software package or tool release / other
output type: internal / demo / preliminary / review-ready / release-ready
report date:
gate mode: real user gate / synthetic gate / mixed
status: draft / revised / ready for Review
Reporting Researcher: researcher agent name or runtime
Reporting Reviewer: reviewer agent name or runtime / skipped
reviewer file: docs/reviewer-agents/reporting-reviewer-agent.md
reviewer mode: critique-only / edits explicitly authorized by user / skipped
Reporting Review status: pending / completed / skipped
researcher-agent response status: pending / completed / not applicable
Input
Status
Notes
Approved Plan Package
Modeling Package
exploratory demo phase summary, if used
Modeling Gate decision
run manifest
run log
run summary
Reader-Facing Deliverables
Deliverable
Path
Audience
Status
Notes
user / reviewer / collaborator / public
draft / ready / limited / release-ready
Evidence object
Type
Path or source
Provenance status
Validation status
Notes
raw input / processed data / extracted text / table / figure / code / log / prompt / model output / other
traceable / partial / missing
validated / preliminary / failed / not checked
Data and Source Provenance Summary
Item
Raw host
Official source or owner
Documentation source
Citation/source reference
Version or access date
License/access status
Method and Execution Summary
approved modeling contract:
actual execution summary:
scripts/notebooks used:
environment path or dependency file:
important tool/model/API versions:
major repairs or deviations:
unresolved execution issues:
Finding
Evidence/artifact
Claim-readiness
Limitation or caveat
Downstream use
supported / preliminary / uncertain / unsupported / not evaluated
can use in Review / needs Modeling addendum / needs Planning addendum / user judgment needed
Use only synthesis that is grounded in the evidence inventory.
Synthesis type
Summary
Supporting artifacts
Confidence
Route
common finding
high / medium / low
Review / Modeling / Planning
complementary evidence
high / medium / low
Review / Modeling / Planning
apparent contradiction
high / medium / low
Review / Modeling / Planning
true conflict
high / medium / low
Review / Modeling / Planning / user
operational tension or tradeoff
high / medium / low
Review / Modeling / Planning / user
evidence gap or uncertainty
high / medium / low
Modeling / Planning / user
Figures, Tables, and Visuals
Visual/table
Path
Source
Main message
Validation status
Caveat
Modeling / Reporting packaging / external source
validated / preliminary / not checked
Output Architecture and Mode-Specific Checks Use only the rows relevant to the selected output mode.
Output mode
Required check
Status
Notes
manuscript or paper
argument architecture and section plan
manuscript or paper
citation-grounded claim map
manuscript or paper
citation integrity and source-support check
manuscript or paper
venue or format fit
manuscript or paper
abstract, conclusion, limitation, disclosure, and availability checks
slide deck
audience, occasion, and narrative order
slide deck
figure readability and caveat placement
web page or interactive report
provenance/caveat placement and interaction checks
web page or interactive report
public-sharing and accessibility/readability risk
dashboard or table package
metric/chart definitions, filters, and interpretation risks
software package or tool release
README, install/run instructions, examples, license/dependencies
software package or tool release
smoke test, validation status, and support boundary
Claim-Evidence and Source-Support Map
Claim or deliverable message
Evidence type
Source/artifact
Support status
Output location
Notes
citation / model artifact / figure / table / user knowledge / limitation
supported / weak / unsupported / unresolved
Modeling Addendum Requests
Request
Why needed
Artifact requested
Within approved contract?
Blocks Review?
yes / no / uncertain
yes / no
Planning Addendum Requests
Request
Why needed
Decision needed
Blocks Review?
yes / no
Limitations and Uncertainties
Limitation
Affected finding or claim
Severity
Disclosure needed
blocker / major / minor / accepted limitation
Check
Status
Notes
evidence package is understandable without reconstructing scattered files
source/data provenance is traceable
validated findings are separated from preliminary observations
uncertainties and failures are visible
missing evidence is routed
deliverables are linked and current
output-mode checks are complete
reviewer-agent findings are resolved or routed
Reporting Reviewer Critique Use docs/reviewer-agents/reporting-reviewer-agent.md before the Reporting Gate when a separate reviewer agent is available and approved.
Finding ID
Reviewer concern
Severity
Evidence or artifact
Route
Blocks Reporting Gate?
RR-1
blocker / major / minor / suggestion / accepted limitation
Planning / Modeling / Reporting / Reviewing / Terminate
yes / no
If Reporting Review was skipped, record why:
skipped reason:
risk accepted:
revisit trigger:
Researcher-Agent Response to Reporting Review
Finding ID
Response status
Change made or planned
Blocks Reporting Gate?
Notes
RR-1
accepted and fixed / accepted but deferred / rejected with reason / needs user decision
yes / no
decision: approve for Review / approve as limited demo / revise Reporting / request Modeling addendum / request Planning addendum / terminate or archive
user notes:
required changes before Review:
approved limitations:
next stage:
main evidence to inspect:
strongest supported findings:
weakest or most uncertain findings:
known provenance concerns:
known validation concerns:
addendum requests:
user decisions needed: